Stop asking ChatGPT which tool to buy.
VerdictBox puts your product options in front of 12 opinionated AI personas. They debate across 3 rounds — then deliver a verdict with full reasoning and dissent you can actually act on.
Live verdict
Linear vs Jira — Project Management
Linear wins
9 of 12 jurors
“Linear’s speed and developer-first UX won the majority. For teams under 100, Jira’s complexity is overhead — not a feature.”
3 dissenting jurors — cited Jira’s advanced reporting and enterprise integrations as decisive for larger orgs.
Sound familiar?
Spent hours on G2 reading conflicting reviews
Asked ChatGPT and got "it depends on your needs"
Built a comparison spreadsheet nobody agreed on
Made a gut call and second-guessed it for months
There's a better way. Get a jury to argue it out.
Simple by design
From question to verdict in minutes
Name your products
Enter 2–4 options and tell us what you care about — budget, scalability, ease of use, support, whatever matters to your team.
12 AI experts argue it out
A jury of 12 opinionated AI personas — skeptics, optimists, pragmatists, power users — debate across 3 structured rounds.
Get a verdict you can act on
A clear winner with full reasoning, every dissenting argument, and a recommendation you can share with your team.
Use cases
Any product decision. Any industry.
If you're comparing options and need a clear answer, VerdictBox can run the deliberation.
SaaS Tool Evaluation
Jira vs Linear vs Asana — which project tool fits your team?
Vendor & Supplier Selection
Comparing three agencies or service providers for a contract?
Platform Migration
Notion vs Confluence — where should your team's knowledge live?
Big-Ticket Purchases
Laptop, camera, or enterprise hardware — get a clear recommendation.
The difference
One answer isn't a decision. A debate is.
Asking a chatbot
- One opinion, no counter-arguments
- Trained to be agreeable — not honest
- No way to see the reasoning
- Can’t represent different user types
- You still have to make the call alone
VerdictBox jury
- 12 personas argue the real trade-offs
- Skeptics push back — no rubber-stamping
- Full rationale you can audit and share
- Personas span roles, priorities, and needs
- Walk away with a decision you can defend
Pricing
Start free. No card, no setup.
5 free verdicts every day. Upgrade to Pro for $12/mo and unlock custom personas, comparison history, and 30 verdicts a day.
Try it now
What product are you deciding between right now?
Takes 60 seconds to set up. The jury does the rest.
Start a free comparison